A historic $5 billion water rights settlement aimed at bringing Colorado River water to the Navajo Nation, Hopi Tribe, and San Juan Southern Paiute Tribe is being blocked in Congress by Upper Basin states. Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming oppose the deal over provisions allowing the tribes to lease their water across basin boundaries, fearing it will establish a threatening legal precedent for their own water security. This political gridlock leaves nearly a third of local tribal households without running water, prolonging a century-old struggle for basic human rights and resources.
**THE WESTERN STAR**
*The Voice of the Great Southwest — Five Cents a Copy*
***
# GREAT DESERT WATER DRAMA!
## UPPER BASIN BARONS PUT THE KIBOSH ON FIVE-BILLION-DOLLAR INDIAN TREATY!
### Thirsty Tribes Left High and Dry While Wealthy Cities Guzzle the Liquid Gold!
### Eighty-Three-Year-Old Hopi Matriarch Hauls Water in Flivver from Livestock Well!
### A Century of Unkept Promises by Uncle Sam Exposed in Sensational Capitol Gridlock!
***
**PHOENIX, ARIZ. —** A desperate drama of thirst, gold, and political skulduggery is playing out beneath the blistering desert sun! The largest tribal water treaty in the history of our great Republic—a monumental deal to secure the life-giving flow of the Colorado River for the Navajo, Hopi, and San Juan Southern Paiute tribes—is on the verge of being sabotaged!
The culprit? A powerful cartel of northern states! Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming—the high-and-mighty sovereigns of the Upper Basin—have thrown a monkey wrench into the gears of Congress, blocking a staggering five-billion-dollar federal windfall that would finally bring running water to the parched desert reservations of Northern Arizona, where one-third of all homes remain as dry as a bone!
***
### THE PLIGHT OF THE MESA: LIFE WITHOUT A TAP!
To understand this tragedy, one must look upon the weathered face of Mrs. Marilyn Tewa, an 83-year-old matriarch who sits on the Hopi Tribal Council. While she debates high finance and water law by day, her own home in the ancient village of Mishongnovi boasts not a single chrome faucet or modern water pipe!
Every other afternoon, this gritty grandmother cranks up her trusty motor flivver, loads five-gallon buckets into the back, and rattles five miles down a dusty trail to a squeaking windmill. There, from a well dug for common cattle, she coaxes the untreated underground flow that keeps her family from perishing of thirst.
"That’s what keeps us alive," Mrs. Tewa declared, her voice steady as she tapped the iron spigot. Back in her kitchen, where her daughter kneads dough for the evening meal, the family must rely on plastic jugs. When nature calls, they must use portable outhouses scattered among the stone dwellings.
***
### THE SPECTOR OF THE OPEN MARKET!
If passed into law, the *Northeastern Arizona Indian Water Rights Settlement Act* would pour $5,000,000,000 in cold, hard federal greenbacks into the territory to lay down iron pipes, build modern pumps, and construct massive treatment plants. It would also carve out a permanent, long-delayed homeland for the San Juan Southern Paiute Tribe.
To help pay the freight for this colossal undertaking, the Navajo and Hopi plans are simple: they intend to lease a portion of their rightful water to the booming, cash-flush cities of the south, like Phoenix.
But this has sent a shiver down the spines of the Upper Basin politicians!
These northern nabobs fear that if water is allowed to be leased across the basin line, it will set a dangerous precedent. They dread a future where thirsty, high-rolling metropolises like Los Angeles and Las Vegas can simply outbid everyone else on the open market, siphoning off the Upper Basin’s own liquid gold!
Negotiators for Utah and Wyoming sent a confidential missive to Uncle Sam’s Senate Committee on Indian Affairs, warning of "significant unresolved concerns" regarding their own state rights. Colorado and New Mexico quickly chimed in with their own stern warnings.
***
### A CENTURY OF FLIM-FLAM AND "TRY AGAIN"
It is a scandal 118 years in the making! Way back in 1908, the Supreme Court ruled that the federal government owed the tribes enough water to live. Yet, for over a century, the basin states have enjoyed a free ride, guzzling the tribes' unused water without paying a single copper cent!
"Everybody is getting free water right now," declared Ethel Branch, a fierce former attorney general for the Navajo, who flatly stated the water had been "stolen for over a century" to fuel a trillion-dollar western boom.
The legal run-around has been relentless. When the Navajo took their fight to the Supreme Court, they were given the cold shoulder by the conservative majority. In a stinging, brilliant dissent, Justice Neil Gorsuch barked that every time the Navajo ask Uncle Sam to keep his promise, they are told to "try again."
"When this routine first began in earnest," Justice Gorsuch wrote, "Elvis Presley was still making his rounds on *The Ed Sullivan Show*!"
***
### THE "HAIL MARY" IN THE SMOKE-FILLED ROOM
Desperate to clinch the deal before a new administration took the reins in Washington, tribal leaders and Arizona officials convened a "Hail Mary" summit in Phoenix in November of 2024.
The Navajo offered a massive, self-sacrificing compromise: they would slash the amount of water they could lease and limit the years of the contracts. They even offered to leave their own water in drought-stricken reservoirs to keep the river flowing downstream.
But the Upper Basin bosses arrived with a laundry list of grievances and refused to play ball.
"We shouldn't be punished for being in two basins," protested Navajo President Buu Nygren, pointing out that their reservation straddles the dividing line.
Meanwhile, the mighty machinery of the defunct Navajo Generating Station—which once powered the canals that quenched the thirst of Phoenix and Tucson—sits dark and silent on Navajo land. The tribes helped deliver water to the white man's cities, yet they are barred from using those very same pumps to wet their own whistles!
***
### "IT'S A MATTER OF HUMAN DECENCY!"
"It’s not about green-grass lawns or golf courses or swimming pools," cried Crystalyne Curley, the passionate Speaker of the Navajo Nation Council. "It’s just basically turning on the faucet to boil eggs for your children, or washing your hands after butchering a sheep!"
Up on the Hopi mesas, Councilmember Marilyn Fredericks walked the dry, stone-carved steps of a terraced garden that hasn't grown a crop in six years. Of the seven natural springs that once fed the village, five have run bone-dry due to over-pumping by outsiders.
Clutching her walking poles, Fredericks looked out over the parched earth. The proposed pipeline, she whispered, would be "our umbilical cord."
"This is evidence of how precious water is to us," she said.
Will Congress find its conscience and pass the bill, or will the water barons of the north keep the Native American high and dry?
*Read tomorrow's edition for the latest dispatch from the Capitol!*